Domestic and The Incredibles 2

In Claudia Nelson’s description on the keyword “Domestic”, Nelson speaks on the definition of domestic and how domesticity is represented in children’s literature. Specifically, Nelson talks about domestic fiction and how tales of the family are told to children. Nelson concludes her description by stating that domestic fiction often portrays that “achieving and maintaining what is domestic..is often neither easy nor pleasant.” We can see this idea maintained in both the literature we read in class and in popular culture. Both the film the Incredibles 2 and Little Women, written by Louisa May Alcott, advance this narrative, that housework and domesticity is strenuous labor.

Both the Incredibles 2 and Little Women speak to ideas about domesticity in ways that paint it as undesirable. In Little Women, Marmee speaks to her children and tells them that she is angry almost everyday of her life. While she instills the values of work in her daughters, she does not pretend that being tethered to her home is joyous work. She states that she wants more for her daughters than to be unhappy housewives. In contrast with this, the Incredibles 2 portrays Mr. Incredible as doing a majority of the domestic labor in the home. In the image above, he can even be seen wearing the baby. Mr. Incredible is tasked with staying home with the couple’s children after his wife is selected to work as a superhero. Mr. Incredible quickly learns domestic work is harder than it seems and longs to work as superhero instead of dealing with the troubles he faces on the home front. Mr. Incredible comes to value the domestic labor his wife performs that he once took for granted only after he experiences it firsthand.

While both representations of domesticity are different in that one is portrayed by a woman and another by a man, both speak to further the idea that domestic labor is undervalued and unpleasant. Marmee and Mr. Incredible carry out these domestic acts as labors of love for their family, each challenging domesticity in their own ways.

3 thoughts on “Domestic and The Incredibles 2”

  1. I find it really interesting how you compared a mother participating in domestic labor vs the father participating in domestic labor. As I watched Incredibles 2, I picked up on the conversations Mr and Mrs, Incredible had about how Mr. Incredible felt about having to stay home with the children will the mother got to go out and perform a job he loves to do. The writers of this movie did a nice job, in my opinion, of incorporating your theme that domestic labor is often undervalued and unappreciated. I think another interesting aspect of the Incredibles 2 movie is to talk about how the oldest daughter, Violet steps in to help with the domestic tasks of the home while the mother is away. Overall, very nice analysis bringing together Little Women and Incredibles 2, along with domesticity!

  2. Emily,
    Great job with this response! I never would have thought of drawing this connection between two seemingly unrelated pieces; however, you do a good job comparing both Mr. Incredible and Marmee to domesticity. I think the quote that you included about domesticity being neither easy, nor pleasant, was the perfect quote to include because it demonstrates that, contrary to popular belief, housework is difficult. In recent times, domestic work has received more recognition as real work, but it is still viewed as inferior to paid labor. It was refreshing to see that Mr. Incredible was doing the housework because traditionally this role belonged to women.

  3. These were really interesting observations. Especially in the Incredibles 2, domestic labor for Mr. Incredible was almost a fate worse than death. It is clear to the audience that he doesn’t see domestic labor as labor at all, and that he will only be fulfilled if he is out working in his field. I also find it interesting that the movie also touches on the misconceptions that domestic labor is not, in fact, actual work. We can see this when Mr. Incredible completely dismisses all concerns from his wife about him being able to handle things and the advice that she offers to him. But, what I think makes this movie unique in terms of the domestic is how these viewpoints evolve throughout the movie. Quickly we see Mr. Incredible learning the difficulties of domestic labor, but we also see him finding joy in it towards the end of the movie. The progression of these ideas in this movie are unique, and that’s why I think this was a really good choice to review domestic. Good job!

    This is common with societies views of

Leave a Reply